Vigna Casi 2020 Review: Castello di Meleto Finds the Right Balance Between Power and Elegance
Not every Chianti Classico Gran Selezione needs to be a muscular, heavily polished red with the aromatic personality of a French oak barrel. The best examples have something more interesting to offer: ripe Sangiovese, firm tannins, properly integrated wood and enough acidity to remind you that Tuscany makes wines for the dinner table, not just the tasting room.
Castello di Meleto’s Vigna Casi 2020 belongs to that more convincing category. Produced entirely from Sangiovese grown in a single vineyard near Gaiole in Chianti, it combines generous cherry fruit, earthy complexity and a substantial tannic structure with the freshness expected from the northern part of the appellation.
The 2020 is not a delicate Chianti Classico. It has concentration, a broad palate and considerable ageing potential. Yet the wine’s structure remains recognisably Tuscan, with lively acidity and an attractive savoury character preventing the ripe fruit from becoming excessively sweet.
At €52 from the producer, Vigna Casi 2020 is a very good Gran Selezione, offering genuine vineyard identity, carefully managed oak and enough complexity to justify its position above ordinary Chianti Classico. It is still relatively youthful, and its tannins deserve more time, but the quality of the fruit is already apparent.
The Basics
- Producer: Castello di Meleto
- Wine: Vigna Casi Chianti Classico Gran Selezione
- Vintage: 2020
- Appellation: Chianti Classico DOCG
- Classification: Gran Selezione
- Region: Gaiole in Chianti, Tuscany, Italy
- Grape: 100% Sangiovese
- Vineyard: Vigna Casi, below the medieval village of Vertine
- Altitude: Approximately 450 metres above sea level
- Soils: Clay, sandstone and galestro
- Harvest: Manual
- Vinification: Temperature-controlled fermentation, followed by extended skin contact
- Ageing: 27 months in large Slavonian and French oak casks, with a smaller portion in tonneaux
- Alcohol: 14% ABV
- Bottle size: 750 ml
- Farming: Organic
- Serving temperature: 16–18°C
- Drinking window: 2026–2038
- Price: €52 from the producer
Castello di Meleto: A Medieval Fortress with a Modern Vineyard Philosophy
Castello di Meleto stands above the hills of Gaiole in Chianti, where its imposing medieval architecture has been part of the landscape for centuries. The castle’s documented history reaches back to the thirteenth century, when its strategic position between Florence and Siena made it an important fortified settlement.
Today, the surrounding estate is one of the substantial wine-growing properties of Chianti Classico.
Its vineyards occupy different elevations, exposures and soil formations, an advantage that allows the winemaking team to explore several interpretations of Sangiovese without leaving the same geographical area.
The estate’s modern development has placed increasing emphasis on understanding these differences.
Rather than relying exclusively on a broad regional blend, Castello di Meleto has identified individual vineyards capable of producing wines with distinctive personalities.
Vigna Casi and Vigna Poggiarso are particularly important examples.
Both produce Sangiovese-based Gran Selezione wines, but they emerge from different growing conditions and are not intended to offer identical expressions of Chianti Classico.
This approach gives the estate’s most ambitious bottles a clearer geographical identity.
It also makes Vigna Casi a more interesting wine to examine than an anonymous premium selection assembled solely for concentration and power.
The objective is not simply to produce the richest Sangiovese available, but to preserve the particular character of one vineyard through careful cultivation and maturation.
Vigna Casi: Sandstone, Galestro and the Woods Below Vertine
Vigna Casi lies in a valley beneath the medieval village of Vertine, near Gaiole in Chianti. Its defining feature is the combination of relatively warm vineyard soils and a cooler local climate, influenced by the surrounding woodland.
The vineyard occupies approximately 450 metres above sea level and contains different geological formations.
Clay contributes to water retention, particularly important during dry summer periods. Sandstone is more prominent on the western side, while galestro characterises parts of the eastern exposure.
Galestro is a flaky, schist-like sedimentary formation commonly associated with the Chianti Classico hills. Its tendency to fracture and weather influences soil structure, drainage and vine development.
These differences create a varied growing environment even within the same vineyard.
Some parcels experience greater warmth and water availability, while others encourage slower ripening and different patterns of vine growth.
The surrounding woodland also helps moderate the vineyard’s microclimate.
During the hottest periods, this combination of exposure, elevation and local conditions can help preserve freshness as Sangiovese approaches full maturity.
That matters because the grape requires time to develop ripe tannins without sacrificing its natural acidity.
The 2020 demonstrates this relationship particularly well.
The fruit is generous, but there is no impression that ripeness has overwhelmed the wine’s structure. Cherry and darker berries remain balanced by firm tannins and a lively, savoury finish.
Vigna Casi also includes a small area trained as alberello, or bush vines, adding another dimension to the vineyard’s agricultural character.
The wine is therefore not merely a selection of the estate’s best grapes. It represents a specific hillside, with its own combination of soils, exposure and climatic influences.
Why 100% Sangiovese Matters
Vigna Casi 2020 is made entirely from Sangiovese, the grape that gives Chianti Classico its characteristic acidity, floral aromas and firm tannic structure.
Sangiovese is not particularly forgiving.
Harvest too early and the wine can become angular, with aggressive tannins and excessively sharp acidity. Harvest too late and it risks losing the freshness that makes the variety so distinctive.
The challenge is to achieve phenolic maturity while retaining balance.
At Vigna Casi, the combination of relatively warm soils and a cooler vineyard environment offers favourable conditions for that process.
The finished wine has substantial fruit concentration, but its acidity and tannins remain central to the experience.
There is an interesting distinction between Sangiovese and the international varieties frequently associated with prestigious Tuscan reds.
Cabernet Sauvignon can contribute greater density, while Merlot often provides a softer middle palate. Neither is necessary when Sangiovese achieves sufficient maturity and develops the structure required for extended ageing.
Vigna Casi demonstrates that a single variety can provide both generosity and definition.
For a deeper look at the grape’s history, characteristics and remarkable differences between Tuscan growing areas, see our Sangiovese wine guide.
The 2020 Vintage: Ripeness Without Excess
The 2020 vintage produced many successful wines throughout Chianti Classico, particularly where producers managed summer heat and water availability carefully.
Warm periods encouraged good fruit maturity, while the region’s differences in altitude and exposure helped individual vineyards preserve acidity.
The result was an attractive opportunity for Sangiovese: generous fruit without necessarily sacrificing its characteristic tension.
Vigna Casi benefited from its distinctive combination of clay-rich soils, elevation and the moderating influence of nearby woodland.
The resulting 2020 has considerable concentration and a structured, persistent palate.
It is more generous than an especially cool-vintage Chianti Classico, but it does not abandon the variety’s traditional personality.
That balance is important for Gran Selezione.
The category sometimes encourages producers to pursue greater weight, longer extraction and more obvious wood influence in an effort to justify a premium price.
Vigna Casi 2020 demonstrates that ripeness and seriousness need not come at the expense of freshness.
How Is Castello di Meleto Vigna Casi 2020 Made?
Vigna Casi 2020 is produced from manually harvested Sangiovese, fermented under controlled temperatures and matured for approximately 27 months in a combination of large Slavonian and French oak casks, with a smaller portion aged in tonneaux.
The grapes are selected and destemmed before fermentation.
The wine undergoes extended skin contact to develop its tannic structure and extract the colour and aromatic compounds characteristic of ripe Sangiovese.
The ageing regime is particularly interesting.
A substantial portion matures in 30-hectolitre Slavonian oak casks, while another rests in 50-hectolitre French oak vessels. A smaller quantity is aged in tonneaux.
The use of large barrels is significant.
Compared with small new barriques, large casks generally expose less wine to oak surface area relative to their volume, allowing gradual maturation without necessarily introducing dominant vanilla or toasted aromas.
Slavonian oak is traditionally associated with the maturation of Sangiovese and Nebbiolo, particularly where producers favour the development of the wine’s natural character over conspicuous wood flavour.
French oak contributes another dimension, while the smaller tonneaux can influence texture and aromatic complexity more noticeably.
The estate adapts the allocation between vessels according to the characteristics of the different parcels within Vigna Casi.
This provides flexibility without abandoning the wine’s central identity.
After 27 months, the result is a structured Sangiovese with developed tannins, integrated spice and enough freshness to support further bottle ageing.
It is a serious maturation regime, but the wood does not need to dominate the finished wine.
Tasting Notes
Colour: Bright ruby red, with subtle garnet reflections beginning to appear at the rim.
Bouquet: Ripe cherry, blackberry and a delicate floral note introduce an expressive, layered nose. Violet and pomegranate add freshness, followed by cedar, dry herbs and an earthy suggestion of woodland floor. The oak contributes restrained spice, but the fruit remains clearly identifiable.
Palate: Full-bodied for Sangiovese, structured and persistent. The attack is generous, with ripe cherry and darker fruit, before lively acidity and substantial tannins provide definition. The texture is dense but not excessively heavy. There is still youthful firmness through the middle palate, accompanied by an attractive savoury character and well-integrated wood.
Finish: Long, dry and slightly balsamic, with sour cherry, delicate spice and a faintly bitter herbal impression. The tannins remain prominent, suggesting that the wine has not yet reached its full maturity.
Our Verdict: Is Vigna Casi 2020 Worth Buying?
Castello di Meleto Vigna Casi 2020 is an excellent Chianti Classico Gran Selezione, particularly for drinkers who appreciate substantial Sangiovese without excessive oak sweetness.
The wine’s greatest strength is the relationship between concentration and freshness.
There is plenty of ripe fruit, but the acidity remains energetic, keeping the palate focused. The tannins are substantial and finely textured, although still firm enough to remind you that this bottle was made for ageing.
The oak regime also deserves credit.
Twenty-seven months of maturation could easily produce a heavy, woody red, particularly in a warm vintage. Instead, the wine retains a recognisable Sangiovese personality, with floral detail, savoury complexity and a persistent cherry character.
It is not entirely without limitations.
The tannins remain a little demanding, and the middle palate has a density that may feel excessive to drinkers who prefer the more delicate, transparent expressions of Chianti Classico.
There is also a noticeable degree of maturation-derived spice. Anyone looking for an extremely pure, almost weightless Sangiovese will find Vigna Casi a comparatively serious and substantial wine.
But the structure is convincing.
The 2020 possesses enough concentration, acidity and tannic definition to develop gracefully over the next decade.
An interesting comparison is Ormanni’s Gran Selezione Dugentanni, a wine whose richer, more heavily oak-influenced interpretation illustrates another approach to ambitious Sangiovese.
Vigna Casi is not austere, but its use of large casks gives the fruit and the vineyard greater room to express themselves.
At €52, it is a worthwhile purchase for someone seeking a serious Tuscan red with genuine geographical identity.
That price also places it in competition with numerous prestigious Chianti Classico Riservas and some excellent Brunello di Montalcino bottlings.
The Gran Selezione classification alone is not sufficient reason to choose it over those alternatives.
What makes Vigna Casi attractive is the combination of single-vineyard origin, mature Sangiovese, balanced extraction and a thoughtful approach to oak.
The wine can be enjoyed now, preferably after approximately one hour of aeration, but I would be inclined to leave it in the cellar for another three or four years.
Its structure suggests a satisfying drinking window extending into the late 2030s, although I would not purchase it exclusively for very long-term collecting.
Serve at 16–18°C in a generous red-wine glass.
Price
€52.00.
Food Pairings

The wine is particularly attractive with substantial meat dishes, slow-cooked sauces and aged cheeses. Try it with lasagna alla Bolognese, Roman roast lamb, beef braised in Amarone, stout-braised beef stew, beef empanadas or a homemade hamburger.
For a contrasting expression of ambitious Tuscan red wine, our Tignanello 2020 review explores a very different interpretation of Sangiovese and its relationship with international varieties.
